robruckus65

Tis the season for battles and here comes another. This time Edzer has been challenged by cookiemonster. The theme is freestyle.

Here are the entries:

Edzer:


cookiemonster:


Please vote for the siggy you like best. Good luck to both of you.

Loouis

So it began =o

Gl both ^_^~

Edzer

is it just me or are the siggys not showing up?

__________________

Ava by Odsium
Moar;
Odsium

robruckus65

yeah I dont know why it did that...heh... but I fixed it......

__________________

cookiemonster

i saw a box and x b4 but now its okay. gl Edzie.

woow rob. ur pretty quick.

__________________
gift below..

Loouis

I didn't saw anything
Thought they didn't PM'd their pics.

Edzer

Yeah, good luck to you 2

__________________

Ava by Odsium
Moar;
Odsium

Euphie

I'm going with Edzer. Despite how once again the render seems to be too sharp (to clarify, too sprite-ish when it doesn't seem to have started off as a sprite) and have slightly too much saturation at parts, overall it is a good piece. The lighting is great, it matches overall, and the colors in the shadows compliment the render. Good job to both of you.

__________________

robruckus65

hmmm... edzer gmv... the tedxt is real nice... great lighting and fx... good depth too... the render does look a little over sharpened but it doesnt really take away from the siggy much imo... nicely done man...

__________________

Kyon-Kun

Cookiemonster gmv, Edzer's is indeed extremely sharp o.0 i can see squares around the hair area, I liked the bottom right in Edzer's sig but the person is too sharp, In Cookiemonster's, I like the lighting but everything else is pretty plain imo both are fairly plain so Cookiemonster gmv by a small detail, the person isn't very sharp, good job to both of you kiu

__________________

Thx to Wildest Drake ^

Thx to Rotaku^

Expertee

sorry Edzer but thats way too oversharped, saying "a little" is cutting it quite short, but even like that its a hard decision to make.

__________________
.
.

FIGHT5

Edzer's sig is too sharp and i dislike the orange light it seems to be misplaced and distracting. Therefore, i went with Cookiemonsters

robruckus65

hmmm... we need a tie breaker... the voting is supposed to be over but it cant end with a tie... so it is now in sudden death... so for the next vote please post who it is you are voting for with a good reason...

__________________

Kirky

Ok ill vote cookiemonster because edzars render is over sharpened and theres some space where nothing is haperning.

__________________

cookiemonster

i will be the tie breaker!! lol.

__________________
gift below..